SAT standardized testing — Ivy League vs. UC Admissions Debate

SAT standardized testing
Students protest against the reintroduction of college admissions standardized tests (SAT/ACT) at the UCSF Mission Bay campus on the 17th. [Captured from New York Post]

As Ivy League universities such as Harvard and Yale have successively revived mandatory SAT standardized testing and ACT requirements, the University of California (UC) system has also begun serious discussions on whether to reintroduce the exams.

The controversy is intensifying as approximately 3,000 UC professors demand the reinstatement of the tests, while students push back with protests.

According to the Los Angeles Times and the California Post on the 18th, the UC Academic Senate held a meeting on the 17th to listen to experts’ opinions on the reintroduction of the SAT and ACT. The core debate focused on whether standardized testing serves as an objective standard to gauge students’ academic capabilities or a means to reveal educational disparities caused by family background.

The UC system eliminated the SAT and ACT from its admissions process in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic and fairness controversies. However, as the issue of declining foundational academic skills among incoming freshmen has recently surfaced, voices calling for the reintroduction of tests are growing louder.

In fact, according to a report released by UC San Diego (UCSD) last year, the number of incoming freshmen lacking high school-level math skills has surged about 30-fold since 2020. This accounts for 1 out of every 12 freshmen, and 70% of them were found to fall short of middle school levels.

Similarly, UC Berkeley reported that 20% to 30% of students enrolled in introductory calculus courses have revealed severe deficiencies in foundational academic skills for three consecutive years.

In response, more than 3,000 out of approximately 20,000 UC faculty members signed an open letter urging the reinstatement of the exams.

Joel Hass, chair of the UC Davis Department of Mathematics, argued for mandatory testing, stating, “Standardized tests are virtually the only objective indicator available to compare the academic preparedness of students coming from different high schools.” He added that traditional evaluation methods have lost reliability due to grade inflation and the use of artificial intelligence (AI) for admissions essays.

Conversely, UC Berkeley economics professor Jesse Rothstein countered, “While the SAT is somewhat useful in predicting college performance, the scores significantly reflect family background.”

John Friedman, an economics professor at Brown University, emphasized the necessity of the tests, citing an analysis of 12 elite private universities showing that students who scored 1,600 on the SAT had a first-year college grade point average (GPA) 0.43 points higher than those in the 1,200 range.

Views are also divided within the UC Academic Senate. While some senate members raised the need for tests, Maria Anguiano, chair of the Academic Senate, stated that retention and graduation rates are more important. In fact, UC’s first-year retention rate reached an all-time high of 93%, and the 4-year graduation rate recorded 74%.

Student backlash is also fierce. On the 17th at UC San Francisco (UCSF), about 100 students staged a protest against the reintroduction of standardized tests. Candice Phan, president of the UC Student Association (UCSA), criticized that “standardized testing restricts college admission opportunities for low-income and students of color.” Students maintain that remediation and expanded academic support must precede any test reinstatement.

Meanwhile, all eight Ivy League universities have resumed test mandates or announced plans to implement them. Stanford University, MIT, and Caltech have also decided to mandate tests, and USC is re-evaluating its related policies.

UC’s final decision is scheduled to be made by June of next year. Current applicants and applicants for the fall semester of next year are not required to submit test scores, and it remains uncertain whether the testing system will be re-applied starting with applicants for the fall 2028 semester.