gamified credit cards — Are Random Rewards Fueling Overspending?

gamified credit cards
As ‘gamified cards’ emerge where rewards change with every card payment, concerns are rising that they may fuel overspending and gambling tendencies. [Reuters]

Cards that offer varying rewards with every use, known as gamified credit cards, are emerging one after another.

While the stated intention is to make financial services more entertaining, concerns are being raised that randomized rewards may encourage overspending and gambling-like behavior.

According to recent reports from the LA Daily News, fintech companies are leveraging card products that combine uncertainty and random rewards to target younger consumers who are digital and gaming-savvy.

Traditional credit cards have also long utilized gaming elements to influence user spending behavior. A prime example is the sign-up bonus, which awards tens of thousands of points if a user spends a set amount within a specific period.

In the past, the Bilt credit card required users to make at least five transactions per month to earn points on rent payments. Some users even purchased bananas individually to meet the condition. However, Bilt eliminated this requirement when introducing new card products this year.

While gaming elements are not inherently negative, the issue arises when gamification edges close to gambling. Some recently introduced cards are designed so that reward amounts are randomized or large benefits can be won through sweepstakes.

Robinhood ran a promotion from October 26 to November 13 allowing users to spend 500 accumulated reward points to enter a $100,000 sweepstakes.

Such events are not necessarily problematic as long as users do not spend more money than usual or recklessly exhaust their points just to win a prize. However, if they increase spending to secure rewards, it can easily lead to overspending.

Fintech startup Coverd is developing a card product where the cashback accumulation rate varies depending on the time of day, category, and transaction amount. Currently accepting waitlist applications under the name ‘Rich Card,’ it boasts up to 100% cashback.

While the base accumulation rate is 0.5%, the rate can increase significantly during special reward time slots applied to specific industries and transaction amounts. However, actual benefits vary depending on checkout conditions and approval timing.

Matthew Goldman, founder of fintech consulting firm Totavi, pointed out that the product structure is overly complex, noting that users might be tempted to split transactions into multiple payments to maximize rewards.

Experts advise that those interested in using gamified cards should start with small amounts to test them out and rely on cards with predictable, steady rewards for the majority of their purchases.