non-religious voters — Rapidly Growing Political Force Reaches 27%

non-religious voters
The non-religious group, which grew to 27% of total voters in the midterms, showed a high approval rating of 78% for Democrats. Voters lined up at a Fullerton polling place on the 3rd of last month.

As non-religious voters rapidly increase in numbers, they are emerging as a major political force capable of swinging election outcomes across the United States.

The share of voters with no religious affiliation has shown steady growth. According to exit polls from NBC covering past presidential and midterm elections, the proportion of non-religious voters rose from 15% in 2016 to 22% in 2020, 24% in 2024, and reached 27% in the 2026 midterms.

Data from CNN and NBC exit polls indicate that the Democratic support rate among non-religious voters in the recent midterms hit 78%, significantly outpacing Protestant voters at 40% and Catholic voters at 50%. This marks a 7 to 8 percentage point increase compared to the 2024 presidential election, where non-religious support for Democrats stood at 70% in CNN polls and 71% in NBC polls.

The Growing Influence of Non-Religious Voters in Key Elections

The impact of non-religious voters was particularly striking in the Kansas Senate race. Adam Hamilton, a Methodist minister who led a mega-church, won election to the U.S. Senate from Kansas as a Democrat—a milestone not achieved in nearly a century.

Although Hamilton front-and-centered Christian principles throughout his campaign, he secured only 37% support from Protestant voters and 48% from Catholics. In stark contrast, 81% of non-religious voters backed him.

A similar dynamic unfolded in Texas. James Talarico, a Democratic U.S. Senate candidate and Presbyterian seminary student, won 40% of Protestant voters, 60% of Catholics, and an overwhelming 78% of non-religious voters.

In Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed, a Muslim candidate who won a U.S. Senate seat, captured 38% of Protestants and 41% of Catholics. However, he drew strong attention by pulling 76% of non-religious voters and 68% of non-Christian voters.

Why Non-Religious Voters Backed Candidates Highlighting Faith

Non-religious voters even cast overwhelming ballots for candidates who openly emphasized Christian faith. This trend suggests these voters do not necessarily oppose religious politicians, but rather object to the imposition of specific religious beliefs onto government policy and public life.

While the precise drivers behind the solidified Democratic alignment of non-religious voters remain complex, religion researchers and secular organization representatives point to a strong backlash against the Trump administration’s integration of religion and politics.

Fish Stark, executive director of the American Humanist Association, evaluated the election as a powerful rebuke against Christian nationalism and authoritarianism. Hooman Noorivera, research director at Socioanalytica Research, explained that non-religious voters expressed frustration over how Donald Trump, Vice President JD Vance, and War Secretary Pete Hegseth invoked Christianity to justify the war in Iran and immigration enforcement policies.

At the state level, Texas education policies sparked intense debate. Governor Greg Abbott has continuously pushed measures like mandating the Ten Commandments in public schools, permitting chaplains on campuses, and establishing school voucher systems utilizing public funds for religious education. A September poll by the Washington D.C.-based Public Religion Research Institute revealed that 87% of religiously unaffiliated respondents oppose or feel skeptical about Christian nationalism.

Economic Concerns vs. Secular Values

Some analysts argue that voter sentiment cannot be entirely explained by the backlash against religion-politics integration. Ryan Burge, a professor at Washington University in St. Louis, raised the possibility that economic issues drove the Democratic preference among the non-religious. Prior to the midterms, a Pew Research Center survey found that 83% of religiously unaffiliated voters considered the economy a very important factor in their vote, suggesting the election centered heavily on the cost of living rather than purely secular or social values.

Historically, political parties have struggled to systematically mobilize this demographic. Non-religious voters often harbor a deep distrust of institutional organizations, making them difficult to organize or target effectively.

Furthermore, experts note that non-religious voters do not function as a monolithic political bloc. As Professor Burge noted in his 2023 book ‘The Nones’, they lack a single unifying definition, spanning progressives, conservatives, younger and older individuals, men, and women across diverse racial backgrounds.

Nevertheless, some maintain an optimistic view of their organizing potential. Stark noted a rising number of individuals identifying explicitly as humanists, atheists, or agnostics. When non-religious people bond over humanistic values or civic activities rather than just a shared lack of religion, sustainable community organization becomes possible.

Steven Emmert, executive director of the Secular Coalition for America, emphasized that as non-religious voters approach 30% of the electorate, future candidates can no longer afford to ignore them. The recent midterms also made clear that a non-religious surge does not inherently disadvantage religious politicians.

As political strategists digest the midterm outcomes, engaging this emerging demographic stands out as a critical challenge ahead of the 2028 presidential election, requiring parties to understand their economic concerns and demands for religious freedom.